Skip to Content

Best Peanut Butter Whiskey

When we first catch sight of whiskey, there are certain ambiances and aromas that come to mind.

It’s perceived as a traditional drink that holds just a touch of class to it, but not too much because it must maintain that slightly rugged and spicy demeanor somehow.

Really get in touch with your mind, what does whiskey mean to you? Drinks can hold memories in us and sometimes whiskey is the drink of the soul because of how smooth and rich it is.

If you can get in touch with that memory, you can enjoy whiskey on another level. There’s a reason it holds stereotypes to the finer things in life.

So, whiskey is actually the anglicized Gaelic word which means “the water of life”, if you’re Irish you’ll understand that to a T. Whiskey is predominantly worldwide distilled, however, some of the most popular brands and oldest whiskey origins begin in Ireland and Scotland, and develop into European countries.

The art of distillation spread to Ireland and Scotland no later than the 15th century, actually, the earliest mentioning of whiskey in Ireland comes from the seventh century.

This alcohol certainly has an old history and it’s as strongly rooted as the taste of whiskey itself.

Whiskey is actually made via distillation of fermented grains and the very first records of this process were found in the archeological digs of millennia BC Babylon and Mesopotamia.

The various grains are used and whiskey is typically aged in wooden casks, which are actually often old sherry casks, which explains the similarities in taste that whiskey and sherry have in common. 

Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey | ReserveBar

Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey ReserveBar

This whiskey is more than just a shot for certain, it can be enjoyed neat, just as it is. And that extra added sweetness from the peanut butter makes it even easier to sip on all night long without a care in the world.

That’s exactly how you should be enjoying your whiskey! This whiskey is like a duo in disguise, on one side you get the smoothest and boldest distilled whiskey, on the other, you get a rich, and irresistible peanut butter spread which flavors the whiskey beautifully.

It’s extremely useful for those late-night cravings, sipping on a glass of Skrewball’s peanut butter whiskey (see also: Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey Review)just hits the right spot.

They’re not two flavors that one would think would go together so well, but they blend together phenomenology. Perhaps it’s because of how luxurious both of these items are individual!

Peanut butter is rich in flavors and whiskey is as smooth as day. It’s rather difficult to just enjoy one glass of this spectacular mixed drink so a fair warning now, your night may get extremely nutty! 

Skrewball’s peanut butter whiskey also may enable you to detect notes of roasted peanuts, honey, vanilla, and toasted flavors.

Roasted peanuts can be a bit on the salty side as expected, so the vanilla and honey help sweeten up the drink as a whole and leave your tastebuds and soul craving more from this whiskey. Also, there is no chilling or chaser required with this whiskey(see also: Best Chasers For Whiskey [22 Ideas])!

Skrewball have their very own cocktail recipe available on Reservebar for you to experiment with and enjoy!

You’ll need 1.5 ounces of Skrewball peanut butter whiskey, 0.75 ounces of Templeton Rye, 4 dashes of Angostura Bitters, and a cherry to garnish.

Simply build these ingredients up together in an old-fashioned glass, stir until properly chilled, and garnish with an orange peel and a cherry! It really does not get any simpler than that. 

Peanut butter was actually a brand new and fascinating addition for the co-founder of the brand, Steve, after immigrating as a refugee from Cambodia. Needless to say, he was hooked immediately.

He went on to develop a best-selling peanut butter whiskey at his bar and restaurant in Ocean beach. He then teamed up with his wife, who was a lawyer and chemist, to develop a spirit that tasted fantastic on its own, mixed well in cocktails, and played great as an ingredient. The result was Skrewball!


  • Can add on gift options – customized engraving with a personal message 
  • Handmade leather and velvet bottle holders – available to purchase individually
  • Exceptionally Mixable – elevates your favorite cocktail recipes


  • Recommended to drink responsibly – strong alcohol content 

Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey is also available on Drizly 

Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey | ReserveBar


There’s nothing smoother than whiskey, correct? Well, we believed so until we discovered Ole Smoky Peanut Butter Whiskey on Reservebar that encapsulates the smoothness of whiskey with a sweet and creamy flavor of peanut butter.

When blended perfectly, with their smooth whiskey, this peanut butter adds a kick to a traditional sipping drink. When searching for your new favorite whiskey to enjoy, you want something smooth, rich, smokey, and sweet overall.

These flavors and characteristics are the combinations of dreams and if you can find something that balances them out well, you’ll have hit the jackpot of whiskey sipping!

We got ourselves a bottle for the office on games night and let me tell you, it literally went down like a dream!

Whiskey is a particular drink that many of us enjoy but some don’t, and the ones wh usually stick to fruity cocktails adored the sweet and sensual nature of this peanut butter whiskey. It’s perfect for friendly get-togethers, or as a stand-alone drink for one on a long weekend.

The design on the bottle is also one to take note of, whiskey isn’t just about the taste and aromas, it has to look the part too! So, the bottle should look as refined and sophisticated as the drink inside, with a spicy edge to it.

The color is also just divine, it’s rich in caramel coloring that beautifully represents the sweetness of the peanut butter flavors inside. 


  • Luxury drawstring holder available – the perfect gift 
  • Custom engraving – for a special friend or loved one 
  • Smokey and sweet – spectacular flavors 


  • Subject to availability – some states may not have this whiskey available

Ballotin Peanut Butter Chocolate Whiskey Price & Reviews | Drizly

Ballotin Peanut Butter Chocolate Whiskey

Whiskey is the type of drink that reminds us of the finer things in life, it is subject to its traditional and classic taste and nothing can beat the original taste of distilled whiskey in an old-fashioned glass.

Except maybe for this Ballotin peanut butter chocolate whiskey! This brand is flavored whiskey straight from Kentucky, United States.

The most popular and common size available for this whiskey is 750ml, however other sizes are available to purchase if need be. It’s also 30% ABV so it’s certainly some of the strongest stuff available. 

Whiskey is rather diverse for its ability to provide notes of many flavors to its consumers, sometimes the longer it’s aged for, the stronger the taste!

So, try it for yourself and tell us which of the following notes were the strongest that you were able to pick up in this particular whiskey.

You may detect notes of chocolate, peanut butter, roasted peanuts, and smooth liquor for a blend that is truly spectacular. 

We love the design from the bottle itself, let alone the drink inside. The color of the whiskey inside resembles a chocolatier’s best dream and it truly does make you feel like you’ve stepped foot inside a chocolate factory from the heavens above.

We also all know how well chocolate and peanut butter go together, so don’t miss out on the chance to try it out in a true show stopper of whiskey drinks.

The sweetness of the chocolate, with the salty peanut buttercream, and the smooth distilled whiskey, all make for a blend that will put you to sleep with ease any day of the week. 

The bottle design just screams whiskey in all its Irish and Scottish roots and we love the color scheme too! We got a bottle for ourselves and it made for a fantastic gift for my whiskey-loving friend!

This whiskey went straight into their collection and comes out only on the rarest of occasions to save it as much as possible.


  • Beautiful bottle design – professional and sentimental
  • Chocolate and peanut butter-infused alcohol – what’s not to love?
  • A delicious take on a classic – like no other whiskey blend available 


  • Won’t be able to buy any other brand – your brand loyalty may be tested!

Texas Ranger Peanut Butter Whiskey Price & Reviews | Drizly

Texas Ranger Peanut Butter Whiskey

Sometimes you just can’t beat a classically made and traditional whiskey blend, and this one has notes of peanut butter to really present something special to your evenings in. Texas Ranger peanut butter whiskey has aromas like no other whiskey out there.

The saltiness and sweetness to the peanut butter add something extra sweet to the whiskey, which when sipping frequently in an old-fashioned style glass, can be appreciated more.

If you’re drinking it straight, those sweet flavors will be handy for a new whiskey drinker to enjoy their whiskey this way. Also, it could be interesting to see how many aromas you can detect while drinking.

We got our hands on a bottle and the office went down like a ship, let’s put it that way.

And so they should, because whiskey is the type of drink that has the sophistication to do that to a group of people, and get away with it because it’s a classically made drink.

If whiskey were a person, they’d probably be a butler of some kind with just enough sophistication, but a hint of spicy nature to them.

See if you can detect the chocolate flavors inside this whiskey that have been added during the distillation process for your pleasure!


  • 35% ABV – you get exactly what you pay for and more
  • Delicious aromas – including roasted peanuts, sweet chocolate, and light oak notes
  • Great as a mixer – long lasting finish


  • Warning – strong alcohol content 

Shop Bird Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey Near Me | Drizly

Bird Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey

There’s just something about a whiskey bottle with a dog on the front that calls to us and we’re not sure why. It says, ‘drink me and live your best country life’ and so well, we must do what the dog on the bottle says, right?

This bottle seems like it’s wise beyond its years from appearance alone and we know the drink inside is aging like fine wine for all to taste.

You could easily imagine a wise hunter or sophisticated gentleman sitting down at the end of his busy day to a smooth glass of shop bird dog peanut butter whiskey(see also: Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey Review).

So, let’s get into this whiskey. Well, to start, you may detect notes of warm peanuts with a hint of wood char from a freshly burnt fireplace. It’s so easy to imagine the scene in your mind, so let the whiskey take you there!

The body of the drink is smooth peanut butter flavors that are presented with traditional caramel and vanilla notes. And the finish is a slow burn of warm whiskey that fades into a sweet caramel. 

When we tried this bottle for ourselves, many of us were transported to our luxurious alternative lives out in the countryside that lives deep down in our souls. It just felt right to drink this whiskey and imagine the journey it could take you on personally. 


  • Slow, warm finish – caramel and vanilla notes
  • 40% ABV – classic and pure whiskey
  • Nutty flavor – exactly what you want from peanut butter flavored whiskey


  • May replace your old favorites – hard to come back from!

SQRRL Peanut Butter Whiskey Price & Reviews | Drizly

SQRRL Peanut Butter Whiskey

Our last pick of the day is a traditional and well-loved peanut butter whiskey, SQRRL peanut butter whiskey.

It’s available in a 750ml bottle, and a 50ml bottle as well as subject to availability on other sizes, so there’s a size preference for all whiskey drinkers out there.

We recommend getting the smaller bottle to start if you’re new to whiskey, and then moving onto the larger for when you’re certain it’s your new favorite brand. 

We tried it and gifted a few bottles to some loved ones who are high up on their whiskey branded journeys, needless to say, they fell in love with this brand because of its simple nature to get the job done, so to say.

If you want a peanut butter whiskey, as plain as day, this brand is the one for one and the quality cannot be matched to any other whiskey out there.


  • Freshly roasted peanuts – balanced with chocolate and butterscotch
  • Lingering sweetness – sweet chocolate and roasted peanuts
  • Amber with golden hues – color is distinct and admirable 


  • Warning – strong alcohol content 

Buyers Guide 

Taste and Aromas 

When choosing your new favorite peanut butter whiskey, consider the taste and aromas when buying.

You’ll want something that is traditional so you get what you pay for in classic distilled whiskey, but also sweet enough to detect the notes of peanut butter in the blend for each sip. A balance of both is ideal. 


Pay attention to the history behind the brand of whiskey you’re buying.

Using peanut butter in whiskey hasn’t been commonly practiced for a particularly long time yet, so if the brand you’re looking into only produces peanut butter whiskey, consider how old their roots are.

The older the family history of the brand, the better, because we often enjoy something the more traditional it has been made. Also, the longer a business has been growing, the better the whiskey over time. 

Frequently Asked Questions 

How Should I Drink My Whiskey?

Well, when it comes down to it, you should drink it however you see fit! However if you’re looking for some guidance because you’re new to whiskey sipping, we can give you some pointers on how to enjoy this drink to its best capacity.

It’s a popular drink because there is no one way to enjoy it truly, there is of course the classical route, pure and neat. No mixers, no ice, and straight. And that is just how some people like it!

But sometimes there’s no fun in that for excitable alcohol drinkers, so why not try adding some water to it to enjoy it slightly lighter, this also can enhance the specific bottle at hands flavors.

Is Whiskey Gluten-Free?

Yes, whiskey is certainly gluten-free. And we’ve got the distillation process involved in making it to thank for this!

The Celiac Disease Foundation concluded that it can safely be considered gluten-free, despite what is used to make it, because of the process of distilling the alcohol.

Although, people with sensitive or celiac disease may have slight reactions from whiskey made with certain grains. So, always check before consuming. 

What Is Whiskey Made Of?

Whiskey is predominantly made of fermented grains that are distilled, usually cereal grains like rye, barley malt, wheat, and corn.

The whiskey undergoes an aging process in oak barrels usually, which can last for a number of years until the drink is fully matured and smooth.

It can also differ in taste and richness depending on the wood used during the aging process, oak wood is the most commonly used wood for its durability and is the best for distilling whiskey.